Credit Managers’ Index (CMI), Economy, eNews
Payment delays rise as customers hold tight to cash

A customer that has paid on time for several years could start falling behind in an instant, as every business fluctuates as it responds to changing economic conditions. This seems to be the case in recent months, as credit managers have noted increases in payment delays and requests for new terms.
By the numbers: The seasonally adjusted combined Credit Managers’ Index (CMI) declined 1.8 points in August, slipping to 54.6. The driving force of this drop was a deep drop in dollar sales, which had seen sharp positive growth the previous month.
Why it matters: Volatility in dollar sales is driven by customer cash flow issues, as more businesses request new terms, pay late or enter payment plans in attempts to preserve cash. Amidst the rise in cash flow struggles, credit managers are increasingly hearing that they cannot be paid until the customer themselves has been paid, further delaying payment.
“We’re seeing customers trying to hold onto their cash for longer, which is presented as requests for extended terms,” said Andrew Perry, CCRA, CICP, senior director, credit and collections at Clean Harbors (Deer Park, TX). “Customers that used to pay us in 30 days start taking 45 days. When it’s a sizable account that’s slowing down, it’s so noticeable. Larger accounts and smaller accounts that have never really had a payment issue in the past are now all the sudden past due.”
Cash flow struggles are impacting businesses of all sizes and across all industries, but those smaller customers will inevitably find it harder to avoid collections. “When I talk to credit managers, they often say that they don’t want to send their larger accounts to collections because they are their biggest customers,” said NACM Economist Amy Crews Cutts, Ph.D., CBE®. “With smaller accounts, especially new ones that show signs of not paying, creditors have very little patience, and they send them to collections. So that is why dollar amount makes a big difference in how accounts are managed.”
The onslaught of requests for new terms is coupled with customers deciding without asking creditors that they will be shifting from 30-day to 45-day terms. “Increasingly I am hearing from credit managers that what is written in their contracts in regard to payment terms and deadlines doesn’t matter to the customer,” said Cutts. “The customer says, ‘Yeah, I know it was net 30 but I haven’t been paid, so you’ll get money when I get money.’ They are deciding to unilaterally rewrite the contract, and there are limited options for what credit managers can do outside of sending them to collections or threatening them with legal actions, which can be expensive.”
For credit managers, these situations prompt a discussion on whether they can stay in business with this customer without exposing themselves to too much risk. “It’s often larger customers that will decide to pay later, and then it is up to us whether we accept it as a business decision,” said Perry. “Our sales and operations teams may push to accept the deal but sometimes they don’t see the risk. It’s my job as a credit manager to find a way to say yes, so I will usually grant the new terms with certain conditions. In some cases, we might require partial prepayment, cash-in-advance or a standby letter of credit.”
Shifts towards later payments and requests for extended terms represent a larger wave of customers holding on to their money in a tougher economy. “CMI respondents have also noted the increase in customers slow paying them to preserve their cash flow,” said Cutts. “What they’re saying is they are prioritizing paying other debts, which makes sense to them from an economic standpoint, but for the credit manager left not being paid it is incredibly frustrating.”
When a customer, regardless of size, seems to be holding tighter to their cash, it prompts credit managers to dig a little deeper to get a sense of what is happening. “When you start to see issues, you need to figure out if it is truly a cash issue or a cash management issue,” said Perry. “A cash management issue could be a problem with their invoicing or turnover in their accounts payable department. But when it’s really a cash issue, you must act fast and get your lien rights or other protective measures you can get in order.”
The bottom line: Customer payment habits shifting as they try to manage cash flow is not inherently risky for the credit department, as long as they recognize it and know how to manage moving forward. With each delayed payment, requests for new terms or other shifts in payment habits, be sure to take the time to determine exactly what is going on with the customer and how to best minimize risk exposure.





